
By Catherine Fitzgerald B.A. M.A. | Published | No Comments
Mid-year reviews are an essential opportunity for managers and employees to check in, provide feedback, and set goals for the remainder of the year.
Conducting effective mid-year reviews can improve employee performance, engagement, and development.
This guide provides managers tips and best practices for making the most out of mid-year reviews.
Mid-year reviews, or performance check-ins, are formal conversations managers have with employees around the middle of the year.
They differ from typical one-on-one meetings in their structure and focus on reviewing progress against goals and creating development plans.
Mid-year reviews provide several benefits:
However, mid-year reviews also come with challenges:
With planning and engagement, managers can maximize the impact of mid-year reviews.
Here are nine tips for conducting high-quality mid-year reviews:
Let employees know the purpose and process of your mid-year review discussions. Share any templates or self-assessments in advance so they can come prepared. Setting expectations upfront leads to more meaningful dialogue.
Have employees assess their performance and progress on goals. Ask them to identify accomplishments, challenges, and lessons learned. Their self-reflection will provide insights to build on in the discussion.
In addition to self-assessments, collect data from other sources – peers, stakeholders, and your observations. Broad input leads to a more complete picture of performance. Maintain confidentiality of data sources.
Discuss the strengths the employee brings to their role. How are they uniquely contributing? Are they using specific strengths more or less than they’d like? Align on priority areas to maximize.
While constructive feedback can feel uncomfortable, understanding perceived gaps is key for improvement. Frame it as helpful insight, not criticism. Focus the discussion on finding solutions.
Review progress against original goals. Which ones need adjustment or greater focus? Are new goals required based on changes over the past months? Align on the most important goals for the rest of the year.
Collaborate on critical skills or knowledge the employee wants to develop. Outline specific on-the-job activities, corporate training, mentoring, or other support that will close development gaps.
Gauge the employee’s overall engagement and satisfaction. Are there issues impacting their work experience for better or worse? Discuss ways to strengthen motivation and commitment.
Close the meeting with clarity on what each of you will do to build on the discussion. Document action steps and follow up if progress stalls.
Here are 8 key steps to structure your mid-year review process effectively:
Block time in advance for dedicated 1:1 meetings with each employee. Allow enough time for thoughtful discussion (typically 45-60 minutes).
One week before, provide employees with self-assessment forms, progress reports, development plan templates, and other materials to review.
Have employees complete self-evaluations and gather their thoughts before the meeting. Managers also reflect on each employee’s performance and look at data.
Meet 1:1 to have an open, engaging discussion. Explore perspectives. Offer constructive feedback. Align on plans forward.
Record critical points, action steps, and development goals that both agree to. Use this to follow up on progress.
Summarize the discussion and next steps in a written document. Share with employees and store a copy for your records.
Continue to discuss progress in your regular 1:1s. Don’t wait until year-end to follow up. Offer ongoing coaching.
Evaluate what worked well and where to improve after each review cycle. Enhance the experience for next time.
Some of the core features that define effective mid-year reviews include:
The benefits of these features include:
For remote employees, mid-year reviews are especially important for staying connected and communicating about performance. Here are some tips for keeping remote employees engaged:
Keeping remote employees engaged through ongoing two-way communication is key for successful mid-year reviews.
Conducting effective mid-year reviews is an essential process for managers to master.
While it requires dedication, time, and effort, the payoff in terms of employee performance, training plans, and engagement is well worth it.
With the proper structure, preparation, and engagement, mid-year reviews can be a valuable tool for achieving team and organizational success.
Managers should invest energy to turn mid-year reviews from a compliance exercise into an impactful business practice.
I always say that I started Oak Innovation because I couldn’t find suitable content for the workshops my clients needed to facilitate. Today, the complete collection consists of 52 editable business and leadership skills workshop packs.
I always say that I started Oak Innovation because I couldn’t find suitable content for the workshops my clients needed to facilitate. Today, the complete collection consists of 52 editable business and leadership skills workshop packs.
Instant Download
Shop All Workshops
Instant Download
Business Skills
Instant Download
Leadership Skills
Instant Download
Limited Time Offer
“I have been using several Oak materials for quite some time. This is a well-structured series relevant to today’s HR professionals. The information is well-organized and easy to understand. Overall, it is a welcome addition to any HR manager's toolkit.” – Bernard Cronin, Director of Human Resources.
“Oak continually attends to the needs of various businesses and either creates or adjusts training modules on various topics to be self-contained, practical, and easy to use. And they stand behind every product with personal service.” – Rey Carr.
“I’ve developed an alliance with Oak — a company that has developed a wide assortment of training “modules” that you can download right now. When you download a module, you own it forever and have permission to edit it, customize it (logos, etc.), and deliver it as many times as you like. You will receive a Word document, PDF, PowerPoint, and comprehensive participant manual; your satisfaction or money back will be guaranteed. The modules are designed for trainers, coaches, and consultants looking to increase their clients' range of products and services. Oak content is also ideal for managers and employees looking to extend their knowledge of organizational, management, and employee titles.” – Tom Heck, President
“Time is money — we all know that. As coaches, our billable time is worth much money, but program development time is not. For a once-off cost per training pack, you’ve saved coaches countless hours of program development time. Plus, because of the high quality of your materials, you make us look good!
What you are offering for coaches is remarkable. Thank you! Thanks, also, for letting us customize the programs with our logos, taglines, etc. Your spirit of generosity is greatly appreciated.
Well done. You’ve put a lot of work into this, and I am thrilled to see the result. All the Best.” – Sylva K. Leduc, MEd (Psychology), MPEC Master Personal & Executive Coach.
“As someone involved in training for over twenty years, I’ve never known a resource as consistently valuable as Oak.
I’m always amazed at their willingness to provide purchasers with their complete range of presentations, regular updates, and new training packages at no additional cost. That makes my purchase increasingly valuable. Their speed in responding to questions is phenomenal.
One of the sessions I often provide is a Training the Trainers workshop. The first resource I encourage people to purchase is the Library of Resources from Oak. These packages have made my job infinitely more manageable, and I recommend them to anyone looking for the highest quality training materials.” – Jeffrey L. Buller, Senior Partner.
Whether you’re just starting out or taking an existing workshop to new levels, our step-by-step workshop packs give you all the tools and training course material you need to fast-track facilitating your workshops — saving you months of expensive trial and error.
Download The Full Workshop Library
The workshop packs are designed for trainers, people managers, entrepreneurs, or business owners who want a consistent way to facilitate workshops without needing to create training content from scratch.
If you're satisfied with your current training workshops and workload, this opportunity may not be a fit for you.
Absolutely - in fact, trainers, people managers, and business owners who've never run business and leadership development workshops before often get the best results because they want to follow a 100% done-for-you workshop format.
Our workshop packs were initially designed for beginners with no prior experience in the field. We provide you with everything you need to facilitate our workshop packs, showing you exactly what to cover, what to focus on, and which workshop content to use.
There's no business speak, no complicated contracts - just straightforward workshop packs that anyone can both follow and facilitate.
Absolutely not - that's precisely why we created ways to save you time, money, and effort. The workshop packs start at $20 each when you take advantage of our special offer.
Unlike other training course material providers that assume you have thousands to "play around with”, our approach is specifically designed for individuals and businesses with fixed budgets.
We've seen endless trainers and business owners start with minimal investment and scale to offering multiple workshop packs - without costing a fortune.
Yes! Everything is created in Microsoft Office, allowing you to easily edit, rebrand, and deliver the workshop packs as needed.
The initial basic setup takes about 5 minutes to download the training content and add your logo. After that, any workshop management requires adding company-specific details to ensure results meet the needs of your audience.
We've specifically designed our workshop packs with an understanding that you may already have a lot to do. Our customers typically spend very little time maintaining workshop packs, giving you back precious time to do what you love.
Most workshop pack providers offer non-customizable training course materials that overlook the needs of their target customer base.
Our workshop packs are designed exclusively for customers, based on real data from 30 years of business experience. While others focus on shiny websites and promises, we've worked out exactly what our client base wants from editable workshop packs.
We've created a streamlined, proven set of 52 workshop packs focused on what actually works in workshop settings today, backed by over 30 years of experience.
Most customers see results instantly from downloading the training content and launching their workshops.
What's exciting is watching what happens when these workshop packs are run inside organizations. While we can't always guarantee specific timelines and results (every workshop situation is different), thousands of customers and teams have already achieved excellent results.
Absolutely! All workshop packs can be delivered under your brand.
This is a digital download. You can print and edit it as your own.